
The grindstone reworked RPG-style, in the same challenging spirit as Challenging Enchanting: harder, but far more rewarding.
Choose ONE enchantment and extract it onto a book, the rest of the item stays untouched.
Nothing is free: every extraction costs resources, levels, and a real risk of losing the enchantment.
✦ Extract Enchantment

Place an enchanted item (or an enchanted book holding several enchantments) and a book, pick the enchantment with the < > arrows and hit Extract.
The enchantment always leaves the item; the enchanted book appears in the Extract panel on the right.
✦ Cost
The price depends on the level of the extracted enchantment:
- Level I: 16 lapis + 8 amethyst + 3 levels
- Level II: 32 lapis + 16 amethyst + 5 levels
- Level III and above: 64 lapis + 32 amethyst + 10 levels
Special enchantments (Mending, Silk Touch, Swift Sneak, Soul Speed, Frost Walker…) cost x2 (items capped at 64).
✦ Diamonds & luck
Extraction is risky: without help the book only keeps the full level 25% of the time. Add diamonds to the bonus slot:
- 0 diamond → 25%
- 6 diamonds → 50%
- 12 diamonds → 70%
- 18 diamonds → 95%
On failure the book gets the enchantment at level −1; a level I enchantment is lost. Only the diamonds of the tier you reach are consumed.
Hover any slot to see the required amounts, the chance tiers and why the Extract button is disabled.
✦ Configuration
Everything is set in disenchantinggrindstone-server.toml (ship it in defaultconfigs/ for your modpack, synced to every player): the item of each slot, the costs per level, the XP levels, the special enchantments and their multiplier, the diamond tiers, and banned extractions per item, tag or globally. By default curses can't be extracted.
# defaultconfigs/disenchantinggrindstone-server.toml [slots] enableBonusSlot = true enableSecondResource = true [items] bookItem = "minecraft:book" resource1Item = "minecraft:lapis_lazuli" resource2Item = "minecraft:amethyst_shard" bonusItem = "minecraft:diamond" [costs] # [level I, level II, level III and above] resource1Costs = [16, 32, 64] resource2Costs = [8, 16, 32] xpLevelCosts = [3, 5, 10] [special] specialEnchantments = ["#minecraft:treasure", "minecraft:silk_touch"] specialCostMultiplier = 2.0 [chances] keepChanceTiers = ["0=25", "6=50", "12=70", "18=95"] [bans] bannedEnchantments = ["*=#minecraft:curse"]
Ban format: "item=enchantment", enchantment id or tag, e.g. "#minecraft:swords=minecraft:fire_aspect" or "*=#minecraft:curse".
✦ Companion mod
Part of the Challenging series with Challenging Enchanting: same look, same config style, same philosophy. Enchanting is earned at the table, and moving an enchantment is earned at the grindstone. Each mod also works on its own.
✦ Info
Minecraft 1.21.1 · NeoForge 21.1.248+ · client and server.
Sneak + right-click with an item in hand keeps the vanilla grindstone.
✅ Free to use in any modpack. ❌ No forks or re-uploads.
✦ Support
If you enjoy my mods, you can buy me a coffee ☕
