Challenging Enchanting

A complete rework of the enchanting table in an RPG adventure style: more challenging, and every enchantment feels earned.

 

The enchanting table reworked RPG-style: harder, but far more rewarding.
Every enchantment is earned, one at a time.

 

✦ Add Enchantment

Place your item or a book with 32 lapis + 16 amethyst + 5 levels, and get 1 random enchantment that fits it.
75% level I · 25% level II — add 8 diamonds to get 50 / 50.
No limit on the number of enchantments: keep enchanting the same item as long as you can pay.

 

✦ Upgrade Enchantment

Hit Switch ⇄, pick an enchantment already on the item with the < > arrows and raise it by +1 level, up to the vanilla maximum.
Diamonds are required to upgrade:

  • Level I → II: 32 lapis + 16 amethyst + 8 diamonds + 5 levels
  • Level II → III and above: doubled cost — 64 lapis + 32 amethyst + 16 diamonds + 10 levels

Hover the item slot to see its current enchantments, and any slot to see the required amounts.

 

✦ Configuration

Everything is set in challengingenchanting-server.toml (ship it in defaultconfigs/ for your modpack, synced to every player): the item of each slot, amounts (1 to 64), XP level cost, level II chances, enabling or removing slots, and banning enchantments per item, tag or globally.

# defaultconfigs/challengingenchanting-server.toml
[slots]
enableBonusSlot = true
enableSecondResource = true

[items]
resource1Item = "minecraft:lapis_lazuli"
resource2Item = "minecraft:amethyst_shard"
bonusItem = "minecraft:diamond"

[costs]
resource1Cost = 32
resource2Cost = 16
bonusCost = 8
xpLevelCost = 5

[chances]
level2Chance = 0.25
level2ChanceWithBonus = 0.5

[bans]
bannedEnchantments = ["*=minecraft:mending"]

Ban format: "item=enchantment" — e.g. "#minecraft:swords=minecraft:fire_aspect" or "*=minecraft:mending".

 

✦ Info

Minecraft 1.21.1 · NeoForge 21.1.248+ · client and server.
✅ Free to use in any modpack. ❌ No forks or re-uploads.

 

✦ The Challenging series

Challenging Enchanting is the first mod of the Challenging series. Same look, same config style, same philosophy: every enchantment is earned. Each mod also works on its own.

✦ Support

If you enjoy my mods, you can buy me a coffee ☕

☕ Support me on Ko-fi

Challenging Enchanting Team

profile avatar
  • 1
    Followers
  • 3
    Projects
  • 77
    Downloads
Donate

More from Rouliane