
The anvil reworked RPG-style, third mod of the Challenging series: harder, but far more rewarding.
No more Too Expensive! and no more hidden prior-work penalty: every cost is shown, every action is earned.
Three tabs: Repair, Merge and Rename.
✦ Repair

Same repair materials and +25% durability per material as vanilla, but enchanted gear is expensive to maintain: each material costs 2 levels per enchantment on the item.
- 1 enchantment → 2 levels per material
- 2 enchantments → 4 levels per material
- 3 enchantments → 6 levels per material…
A repair is capped at 30 levels. An unenchanted item can still be repaired with an identical unenchanted item (vanilla: +12% bonus, 2 levels). Enchanted items must be repaired with their material.
✦ Merge

Place an item and an enchanted book, pick ONE of its enchantments with the < > arrows and hit Merge. The other enchantments stay on the book.
The price depends on the level of the applied enchantment:
- Level I: 16 lapis + 8 amethyst + 3 levels
- Level II: 24 lapis + 12 amethyst + 5 levels
- Level III: 32 lapis + 16 amethyst + 7 levels
- Level IV: 48 lapis + 24 amethyst + 9 levels
- Level V: 64 lapis + 32 amethyst + 12 levels
+2 levels for each enchantment already on the item. Special enchantments (Mending, Silk Touch, Swift Sneak…) cost x2 (items capped at 64).
✦ Diamonds & luck
Merging is risky: without help it only succeeds 25% of the time. Add diamonds to the bonus slot:
- 0 diamond → 25%
- 6 diamonds → 55%
- 16 diamonds → 95%
On failure the item gets the enchantment at level −1 (a level I enchantment is lost), and the enchantment always leaves the book. Only the diamonds of the tier you reach are consumed.
✦ Rename

Exactly like vanilla: type a new name, 1 level. Leave the field empty to remove a custom name.
Hover any slot or value to see the required amounts, the cost breakdown, the chance tiers and why a button is disabled.
✦ Configuration
Everything is set in challengingreforginganvil-server.toml (ship it in defaultconfigs/ for your modpack, synced to every player): repair costs and cap, same-item repair, the item of each Merge slot, the costs per level, the diamond tiers, special enchantments, banned merges per item or tag, book-on-book merging, the rename cost and the anvil wear chance.
# defaultconfigs/challengingreforginganvil-server.toml [repair] levelsPerEnchantment = 2 minLevelsPerMaterial = 1 maxRepairCost = 30 allowSameItemRepair = true sameItemRepairCost = 2 sameItemRepairBonus = 12 [merge] enableBonusSlot = true enableSecondResource = true resource1Item = "minecraft:lapis_lazuli" resource2Item = "minecraft:amethyst_shard" bonusItem = "minecraft:diamond" # [I, II, III, IV, V and above] resource1Costs = [16, 24, 32, 48, 64] resource2Costs = [8, 12, 16, 24, 32] xpLevelCosts = [3, 5, 7, 9, 12] extraLevelsPerEnchantment = 2 chanceTiers = ["0=25", "6=55", "16=95"] specialEnchantments = ["#minecraft:treasure", "minecraft:silk_touch"] specialCostMultiplier = 2.0 bannedEnchantments = [] allowBookOnBook = false [rename] renameCost = 1 [anvil] damageChance = 0.12
Ban format: "item=enchantment", item id/tag or *, enchantment id/tag or *, e.g. "#minecraft:swords=minecraft:fire_aspect".
✦ The Challenging series
Challenging Reforging Anvil is the third mod of the Challenging series. Same look, same config style, same philosophy: every enchantment is earned. Each mod also works on its own.


✦ Info
Minecraft 1.21.1 · NeoForge 21.1.248+ · client and server.
Sneak + right-click with an item in hand keeps the vanilla anvil.
✅ Free to use in any modpack. ❌ No forks or re-uploads.
✦ Support
If you enjoy my mods, you can buy me a coffee ☕
