StatVerdict

Open your bags. Hover an item. Know if it is worth equipping.

StatVerdict gives you clear gear-upgrade verdicts for your Main Spec and your Off Spec. You don't need SimulationCraft, Raidbots or spreadsheets. It is built for players who loot first and sim never: a fast equip or skip answer, right where you already look.

If you chase every 0.1% in a sim, this is not meant to replace that. If you want solid decisions close to best practice, without the toolchain, this is for you.

What you get

• Upgrade arrows in your bags and on tooltips for your Main Spec and your Off Spec, with MS / OS labels for gear already in your loadouts.
• Stat Progress: how close you are to your stat targets, with live weights that follow what you still need.
• Best in Slot and Ranked Trinkets: your goal's lists (Mythic+, Raid or PvP), your progress, and a roomy tooltip with the recommended gems and enchant, plus where to find the item (dungeon or raid and boss).
• Approve: save bag pieces into a virtual loadout for a spec you are not wearing, and compare against the gear you actually intend to play.

Guide: Auto, or choose your tier

Stat priorities, Best in Slot lists and stat targets are copied one to one from the guides (Icy Veins and u.gg), never tuned or changed.

• Auto (the default) follows your own stats. It shows the targets of the next tier you are working toward and moves you up when you cover about 90% of the current one. The title bar always tells you where you stand, for example Auto · Tier 2 · 80% to Tier 3.
• Or pick Tier 1, Tier 2 or Tier 3 yourself, from comfortable to demanding.
• Best in Slot and trinkets follow your tier, so an easier goal never shows gear only the best-equipped players can have.

How it decides

StatVerdict does not simulate your DPS. It uses a practical, explainable priority model:

• Armor and weapons: item level and your primary stat come first. Crit, Haste, Mastery and Versatility follow your build's order, with live pressure toward what you are still missing.
• Rings and necks: they often have no primary stat, so the top secondary is boosted to compare them fairly.
• Trinkets: judged from a Best-in-Slot tier list first, because the proc or on-use usually matters more than the stats on the item.
• Ten or more item levels is a clear upgrade; small steps are decided by the stats. A verdict is the same from both sides: two items can never both be better than each other.

Why StatVerdict

• Fast: answers in your bags and tooltips.
• Two specs: check Off Spec loot without respeccing.
• Honest: a gear coach for real decisions, not a parse optimizer. If its data is missing or out of date, it tells you instead of guessing.
• Self-contained: no website required to get a verdict.

Verdict Points are heuristic, not simulated DPS. Proc and on-use power, encounter mechanics and set-bonus size are outside the model. Guide data is bundled with each release, so update the addon regularly to keep it current.